What Star Wars Stole from Dune
In the vast landscape of science fiction, two iconic films, Star Wars and Dune, have left an indelible mark on the genre. While both films are celebrated for their unique storytelling and imaginative worlds, there are undeniable similarities that suggest Star Wars stole certain elements from Dune. This article delves into the key aspects where George Lucas’s Star Wars franchise borrowed heavily from Frank Herbert’s Dune universe.
1. The Chosen One
One of the most significant similarities between Star Wars and Dune is the concept of the Chosen One. In both films, a young protagonist is destined to save their world from an impending doom. In Star Wars, Luke Skywalker is the chosen one who will bring balance to the Force, while Paul Atreides in Dune is the Kwisatz Haderach, a messiah-like figure who will unite the Fremen and bring peace to the universe. This recurring theme of a prophesied savior has become a staple in science fiction, and both films are guilty of embracing it.
2. The Desert Planet
Another element borrowed from Dune is the setting of a desert planet. In Star Wars, Tatooine is a barren, arid world, while Arrakis in Dune is a desert planet that holds the rare spice melange. The desert backdrop adds a sense of isolation and danger to both stories, making the protagonists’ journeys more challenging and intriguing. The arid landscapes also serve as a metaphor for the characters’ inner struggles and the harsh realities they face.
3. The Spice Melange
The spice melange in Dune is a highly addictive, life-prolonging substance that is central to the plot. Similarly, in Star Wars, the Force is a powerful energy field that binds the galaxy together. While the Force is not a physical substance like the spice melange, it serves a similar purpose by giving characters extraordinary abilities and shaping the narrative. The reliance on these powerful elements adds a sense of urgency and importance to the characters’ quests.
4. The Political Intrigue
Both Star Wars and Dune are rife with political intrigue and power struggles. In Star Wars, the Galactic Empire and the Rebel Alliance engage in a fierce battle for control of the galaxy, while in Dune, the House Atreides and House Harkonnen compete for control of Arrakis. These political conflicts drive the story forward and test the characters’ loyalties, making the films more than just adventures; they are also commentaries on power and corruption.
5. The Mentor Figure
In both Star Wars and Dune, the protagonist is mentored by a wise, older figure. In Star Wars, Obi-Wan Kenobi guides Luke Skywalker, while in Dune, Muad’Dib is mentored by Gurney Halleck and Stilgar. These mentors provide guidance, wisdom, and support to the young heroes, helping them navigate the complexities of their respective worlds. The mentor figure is a classic science fiction trope, and both films utilize it to enhance their narratives.
In conclusion, while Star Wars and Dune are distinct films with their own unique qualities, it is clear that Lucas’s franchise took inspiration from Herbert’s universe. From the Chosen One to the desert planet, the similarities between the two films are undeniable. However, it is important to recognize that borrowing elements from other works is a common practice in the realm of storytelling, and both Star Wars and Dune have contributed to the rich tapestry of science fiction.
