What did Robb Stark do wrong? This question has been a topic of debate among fans of George R.R. Martin’s “A Song of Ice and Fire” series and the television adaptation “Game of Thrones.” Robb Stark, the son of Eddard Stark and Lyanna Stark, is often seen as a tragic figure, but his actions and decisions throughout the series raise questions about his character’s flaws and mistakes.
Robb Stark’s first major misstep was his overconfidence in his own abilities and the loyalty of his bannermen. After the death of his father, Eddard Stark, Robb took up the mantle of the North and declared himself King in the North. However, his overconfidence led him to underestimate the cunning and ambition of his enemies, particularly Walder Frey and his alliance with the Lannisters. Robb’s decision to marry Jeyne Westerling, a lady of the Frey family, was a strategic mistake that ultimately backfired when the Freys betrayed him, leading to the tragic deaths of his mother and sister, Lyanna and Sansa Stark.
Another mistake Robb made was his inability to trust his closest advisors and allies. Throughout the series, Robb’s closest advisors, such as Howland Reed and Theon Greyjoy, were instrumental in guiding him and providing valuable insights. However, Robb often ignored their advice, particularly when it came to dealing with the Lannisters and the South. His blind loyalty to his honor and the North’s interests led him to make poor decisions, such as the Red Wedding, where he and his men were ambushed and slaughtered by the Freys and the Lannisters.
Robb’s lack of political acumen also played a significant role in his downfall. He failed to recognize the importance of forming alliances and securing the support of other noble houses. His stubbornness and belief that he could win the game of thrones through sheer force of will and honor led him to alienate potential allies, such as the Iron Islands and the Dornish. This isolation left him vulnerable to the attacks of his enemies and contributed to his ultimate defeat.
Lastly, Robb’s personal relationships and emotional attachments also hindered his ability to make sound decisions. His love for Jeyne Westerling, despite her being a pawn in the Frey-Lannister alliance, clouded his judgment. Additionally, his loyalty to his siblings, particularly Sansa and Arya Stark, often resulted in him prioritizing their safety and happiness over the greater good of the North. This personal bias led him to make decisions that were not always in the best interest of his people.
In conclusion, Robb Stark’s mistakes were numerous and varied, ranging from overconfidence and poor political judgment to emotional attachments and a lack of trust in his advisors. While he may be seen as a tragic hero, his flaws and mistakes ultimately contributed to his downfall and the loss of the North. The question of what Robb Stark did wrong serves as a reminder of the complexities of power, loyalty, and the human condition in the world of “A Song of Ice and Fire.
